Skip to content

The poisonous tradition at Hamilton’s public faculty board


Bullying, harassment, poisonous work environments: these are phrases we hear all too typically. Whether or not it’s about metropolis councilor Terry Whitehead, disgraced Gov. Common Julie Payette, or the management group at Bell Media, it appears there may be an epidemic of such conduct in our society. And what’s so deeply troubling and astonishing is that these actions are dedicated by individuals in energy who know higher.

How does this occur? How are these behaviors allowed to permeate the tradition of organizations that tout protected work environments free from bullying, misogynistic, sexist or racist behaviours? It’s a disturbing development, and it would not appear to be bettering. A glance into the current historical past of the Hamilton-Wentworth District College Board (HWDSB) may shed some mild on the methods giant organizations enable these points to fester.

Typically these issues begin on the prime. One director on the board was recognized to be a yeller who berated employees as a method of asserting management. That is unacceptable in knowledgeable setting, and it units the tone for others in positions of energy. If the director can do it and get away with it, why cannot I, they could ask themselves.

The board has confronted stories and surveys that define bullying, racism and poisonous work environments within the final 10 years. However when a brand new director was introduced in to enhance the tradition, little modified. In reality, although the director was explicitly warned about troubling conduct of a sure superintendent, this particular person was promoted to an important place, and the problems continued.

Space superintendents play a big position on this adverse tradition. There are too many tales the place lecturers have been walked out of colleges to face self-discipline as a result of they’ve damaged an “unwritten protocol,” which implies lecturers are to not talk on to a superintendent about faculty primarily based points. Nonetheless, these lecturers had been reaching out to assist employees and college students take care of points faculty administration weren’t or couldn’t deal with.

Mix this with a human assets division that has a popularity for being completely vicious when coping with lecturers, and you’ve got severe issues. A former colleague urged the HR division “weaponizes the Faculty Of Academics,” utilizing it to threaten and intimidate each lecturers and union employees, all within the identify of “defending management and the Board model.”

Probably the most impactful bullies within the daily lives of college employees are faculty directors. There have been and are directors who need and belittle employees in numerous methods. They’ve a substantial amount of energy over working situations, and a few brandish their authority like a weapon. These persons are well-known within the system, and any time there are administrative strikes, faculty employees dread dropping an excellent administrator and concern getting one recognized to be an issue.

In a single public case, an administrator recognized to have problematic relationships with largely feminine employees was topic to an inside investigation by the board, primarily based on the complaints of a number of lecturers. The lecturers had been assured one thing was going to be finished, however nothing was, that’s, not till greater than 5 years later when the person was dealing with legal fees. Through the investigation by the OCT, the complaints of those ladies had been trotted out by the board with the intention to construct their case. This felt like a slap within the face of the complainants. Their tales had been deemed not necessary sufficient to take care of the administrator on a human scale, however when legal fees had been introduced, their tales had been raised. They felt betrayed.

The truth is that in all these circumstances, in all these establishments, the issues of bullying behaviors are broadly recognized. So why are they lined up? To guard the model. It is solely when a disaster arises that one thing is finished. The HWDSB has employed a brand new director, Sheryl Robinson Petrazzini. There’s a sense of cautious optimism that she is going to breathe new life into this troubled board. Nonetheless, as one instructor stated, “I hope they do not eat her alive.”

Ken Durkacz is a retired Hamilton educator


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *