Skip to content

Sorry, Not Sorry: The Disingenuous or Honest Public Apologies for Celeb Antisemitism

Congresswoman Ilhan Omar (D-Minn.) in 2016. Photograph: Lorie Shaull by way of Flickr.

On this period of social media and the 24-hour information cycle, there’s a rising phenomenon of celeb antisemitism — public personalities (equivalent to athletes, celebrities, politicians, and journalists) making antisemitic feedback or posting antisemitic materials on their social media accounts.

In lots of instances, following a public outcry, these personalities specific remorse over their antisemitic sentiments and situation a public apology. Nevertheless, not all public apologies are reduce from the identical material. Some are heartfelt and life-changing, whereas others are superficial and duplicitous.

You will need to discern between these public apologies which might be honest and result in profound modifications, and people which might be disingenuous and are mere sticking plasters for a wounded public particular person.

Who’re these public personalities who’ve made antisemitic statements and apologized for them, with a particular deal with those that made profound modifications, and who’ve sought to tug the wool over the general public’s eyes?

Disingenuous Public Apologies

Listed here are the highest 5 celebrities/public personalities whose apologies for his or her anti-Semitic statements have been seemingly superficial and disingenuous (in no specific order):

1. Whoopi Goldberg

In January 2022, Whoopi Goldberg, famed actress and co-host of the every day ABC discuss present “The View,” got here beneath fireplace for claiming that the Holocaust was not about race however was somewhat about “man’s inhumanity to man.” Goldberg pushed the envelope even additional when she clarified her remarks about her on Stephen Colbert’s “The Late Present,” and asserted that the Holocaust was between two teams of white individuals. Within the wake of widespread condemnations (together with from the Auschwitz Memorial), Goldberg apologized and was subsequently suspended from “The View” for 2 weeks, in order that she may “mirror and study in regards to the impression of her feedback from her.”

Nevertheless, lower than a yr later, Goldberg turned the middle of controversy as soon as once more when she said in an interview with Sunday Times that the Holocaust was not initially about race since Jews weren’t visibly distinct from Germans, versus different minorities.

After this second uproar, Goldberg apologized once more and claimed that she solely sought to clarify her earlier feedback and never “double down” on them.

Solely time will inform if Whoopi Goldberg has really discovered the error of her statements or whether or not she is solely apologizing to guard her public place.

2.Jeremy Corbyn

Following an investigation into the proliferation of antisemitism inside the UK Labor Get together, then-Labour chief Jeremy Corbyn apologized in December 2019 for the existence of antisemitism inside his social gathering on a morning discuss present on British TV. Requested to apologize (following his failure to take action days earlier in an interview on the BBC), Corbyn responded that “Clearly I’m very sorry for all the pieces that has occurred,” and that he was coping with the issue.

Nevertheless, however his seeming contrition, Corbyn was suspended from Labor a yr later, after he downplayed the ultimate report on the existence of antisemitism inside the social gathering beneath his management, and claimed that the antisemitism downside had been overblown by the media.

In response to his feedback, the president of the Board of Deputies of British Jews said that, regardless of his earlier apologies, Corbyn “stays a part of the issue and is an obstruction to the decision of the difficulty.”

3.Kanye West

In October 2022, well-known American rapper Kanye West (now referred to as Ye) made quite a few public antisemitic statements, essentially the most well-known of which was his October 8 tweet that he was going to go “dying with 3” on Jewish individuals. Within the fallout that accompanied his antisemitic outbursts from him, Kanye refused to apologize outright for his earlier statements from him, however did say on Piers Morgan’s discuss present that he was “sorry for the people who I damage with dying with. That I brought on damage and confusion.” He mentioned within the interview that he has no affiliation with any hate group and gave a convoluted apology on the finish of a two-and-a-half-hour interview with professor and podcaster Lex Fridman.

Nevertheless, within the two months following these seeming expressions of contrition, West has solely gone additional together with his antisemitic exercise, associating with recognized antisemite and white supremacist Nick Fuentes, discussing a Jewish cabal on the middle of media and banking on the Tim Pool podcast, and happening an antisemitic rant on Alex Jones’s InfoWars.

4. Ilhan Omar

In 2019, Democratic Minnesota Congresswoman Ilhan Omar “unequivocally apologized” after tweeting that US help for Israel was “all in regards to the Benjamins,” a reference to American foreign money. Whereas some defended Omar’s feedback (together with the left-wing Jewish periodical Jewish Currents), her tweet was seen by many as enjoying into the age-old antisemitic trope of Jews utilizing wealth to exert affect over nationwide insurance policies. Omar was instantly censored by each Republicans and Democrats.

A few weeks earlier than her apology for this tweet, Omar expressed remorse over a 2012 submit by which she claimed that the Jewish state was hypnotizing the world whereas committing evil.

Nevertheless, regardless of Omar’s repeated apologies, she continued to precise sentiments that brought on offense to the Jewish neighborhood. In 2021, she defended lumping collectively Israel and america with Hamas and the Taliban, claiming that the Jewish state is similar to internationally acknowledged terror teams in committing “unthinkable atrocities.”

As David Harris, then CEO of the American Jewish Committee, identified in July 2021, Ilhan Omar’s conduct in terms of Israel or the Jewish neighborhood is formulaic: she’s going to make an announcement that the Jewish neighborhood finds offensive and can first attempt to declare that she was misunderstood or belittle those that referred to as her out earlier than finally apologizing for her phrases and promising to study from them. Nevertheless, like clockwork, Omar inevitably then makes one other derogatory assertion, and the cycle begins another time.

5.Marjorie Taylor Greene

Between accusing a Jewish area laser of inflicting a forest fireplace and insinuating that the Mossad killed JFK, Marjorie Taylor Greene is understood for making outlandish and offensive statements.

In Might 2021, the Republican congresswoman from Georgia made a number of feedback evaluating the COVID-19 vaccine and masks mandates to the therapy of Jews in Nazi Germany. Though many referred to as out the firebrand Congresswoman for her trivialization of the Holocaust and diminishing of Jewish struggling, Greene initially denied any wrongdoing. In June 2021, Greene lastly apologized for her remarks about her, saying that she had earlier visited the US Holocaust Memorial Museum in Washington and was “very sorry” for her “hurtful” phrases about her.

Nevertheless, evidently any classes that Greene discovered have since been forgotten. In September 2022, Greene tweeted that US President Joe Biden was like Hitler and referred to him as #NaziJoe, whereas later tweeting a video that had Biden showing like Hitler, surrounded by Nazi symbols and a recording of a Hitler speech popping out of his mouth .

It seems like Marjorie Taylor Greene could have to make one other go to to the Holocaust Museum.

Honest Public Apologies

Listed here are the 4 public personalities whose apologies for his or her anti-Semitic statements have been seemingly real and honest (in no specific order):

1.Nick Cannon

In July 2020, American celeb Nick Cannon made some antisemitic feedback on his podcast, together with that Blacks are the true Jews, in addition to that Jews are poor and have been traditionally “savages.”

Within the aftermath of his feedback and subsequent firing by Viacom, Cannon apologized for reinforcing “the worst stereotypes of a proud and luxurious individuals” and mentioned that he was ashamed of his feedback.

Nevertheless, Cannon went past a mea culpa for his antisemitic remarks. Each earlier than and after his apology for him, Cannon spoke with Rabbi Abraham Cooper of the Simon Wiesenthal Heart and engaged with the American Jewish Committee.

As a part of his path of “atonement,” Cannon wrote quite a few experiences on books about anti-Semitism and helped provoke the Black-Jewish Leisure Alliance.

2.Rick Sanchez

In October 2010, journalist Rick Sanchez was fired by CNN following his feedback on a radio program about each then-host of “The Every day Present” Jon Stewart and the Jewish individuals. Throughout this interview, Sanchez referred to Stewart as a bigot and implied that Jews management the media and aren’t an oppressed minority because of the energy that they allegedly maintain.

Like Nick Cannon, Sanchez didn’t suffice with a easy apology (which he initially gave to each Jon Stewart and the Jewish individuals) however engaged with Jewish neighborhood leaders and took half in a journey of studying and development.

Alongside this journey, he met with Jewish leaders like Abraham Foxman, the then-head of the Anti-Defamation League (ADL), and Rabbi Shmuley Boteach; He traveled to Israel on an ADL-sponsored journey, and spoke on the ADL’s annual convention.

Throughout this journey of repentance, Foxman advised Sanchez that he may put the matter “to relaxation” and wished him properly for his future.

3.Roald Dahl’s Household

Except for writing such youngsters’s classics as “Matilda,” “Charlie and the Chocolate Manufacturing facility,” and “James and the Large Peach,” British novelist Roald Dahl was additionally recognized for being a staunch anti-Semite.

Within the Eighties and Nineties, Dahl made quite a few public feedback in regards to the Jewish individuals, together with the declare that Jews management the media and the assertion that “there’s a trait within the Jewish character that does provoke animosity.”

Whereas Dahl’s descendants may have simply claimed that “the son shall not bear the iniquity of the daddy,” the Dahl household (together with the Roald Dahl Story Firm) spoke out in opposition to the writer’s hated of the Jewish individuals in a public assertion in 2020.

Though the preliminary assertion apologizing for the “lasting and comprehensible damage attributable to a few of Roald Dahl’s statements” was initially revealed quietly, the household additional expanded on the subject in an interview with Sunday Occasions, explaining that “apologizing for the phrases of a much-loved grandparent is a difficult factor to do, however made tougher when the phrases are so hurtful to a whole neighborhood. We liked Roald however we passionately disagree together with his antisemitic feedback about him.”

4. Desean Jackson

In July 2020, American soccer participant DeSean Jackson ignited an issue when he revealed a number of antisemitic social media posts, together with a faux Hitler quote that “Jews will blackmail America,” and one other one that includes the antisemitic chief of the Nation of Islam, Louis Farrakhan.

Within the months following the outcry over his submit, Jackson apologized for them, saying that he was proudly owning as much as his mistake and was additionally “taking the correct steps to coach” himself. As well as, Jackson took half in a Zoom assembly with a 94-year-old Holocaust survivor and accepted invites to go to each america Holocaust Memorial Museum in addition to Auschwitz.

Because the above examples show, it’s extremely straightforward to say “sorry” when caught making antisemitic statements or expressing antisemitic concepts. Nevertheless, to really study from one’s errors and perceive the damage attributable to such remarks, you will need to not solely apologize for these feedback however to actively work with the Jewish neighborhood to make sure that these sentiments don’t reappear sooner or later and assure that the Apology is greater than merely empty phrases on a web page.

The writer is a contributor to HonestReporting, a Jerusalem-based media watchdog with a deal with anti-Semitism and anti-Israel bias — the place a model of this text first appeared.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *